ICMP Redirect Theory VS. Application

Posted by joeqwerty on Server Fault See other posts from Server Fault or by joeqwerty
Published on 2012-10-29T21:36:12Z Indexed on 2012/11/01 5:05 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 663

Filed under:

tcp

|

icmp

I'm trying to watch ICMP redirects in a lab using Cisco Packet Tracer (version 5.3.2) and I'm not seeing them, which leads me to believe that either my lab configuration isn't correct or my understanding of ICMP redirects isn't correct or that Packet Tracer doesn't support/use ICMP redirects. Here's what I believe to be true regarding ICMP redirects:

Routers send ICMP redirects when all of these conditions are met:

The interface on which the packet comes into the router is the same interface on which the packet gets routed out.
The subnet or network of the source IP address is on the same subnet or network of the next-hop IP address of the routed packet.
The datagram is not source-routed.
The router kernel is configured to send redirects.

I have the lab set up in Cisco Packet Tracer as displayed in the image and would expect to see an ICMP redirect from Router1 when pinging from PC1 to PC3. I'm not seeing the ICMP redirect and it looks like Router1 is actually routing all of the packets via Router2. I have IP ICMP debugging enabled on Router1 (and Router2) and I'm not seeing any ICMP redirect activity in either console. I'm also not seeing a route to the PC3 network in the routing table on PC1, which I think confirms that the ICMP redirect is not occurring. I'm using only static routing on Routers 1 and 2. Is my understanding of ICMP redirects incorrect, or is there a problem with my lab configuration or does Packet Tracer not support/use ICMP redirects? enter image description here

© Server Fault or respective owner

Related posts about tcp

TCP RST Reset Every 5 Minutes on Windows 2003 sp2

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Hey, Recently I had a web developer come to me and ask why he was receiving connection errors in his app that was accessing a sql database. So, I went through my normal trouble shooting steps to isolate or reproduce the issue. I discovered that if I connected to the database using Query Analyzer… >>> More
iptables issue on plesk

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
i don't know how to open a specific port (rtmp=1935) on my CentOS server using Plesk or itables. I created new rules for port 1935 i/o using Plesk/Modules/Firewall but this doesn't work. Nmap scanning tells me this : 1935/tcp filtered rtmp . So i decided to have look at my iptable using SSH (iptables… >>> More
Httpd problem, suspect an attack but not sure

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
On one of my servers when I type netstat -n I get a huge output, something like 400 entries for httpd. The bandwidth on the server isn't high, so I'm confused as to what's causing it. I'm suspecting an attack, but not sure. Intermittently, the web server will stop responding. When this happens… >>> More
Why can blocked IPs get through my iptables? What's wrong with this configuration?

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
(Why can/How are) blocked IPs (get/getting) through my iptables? Hello and thanks for your consideration... I have configured iptables and included (below) output from the command "iptables --line-numbers -n -L" yet IP addresses (like 31.41.219.180) from IP blocks I have already blocked are getting… >>> More
iptables syn flood countermeasure

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I'm trying to adjust my iptables firewall to increase the security of my server, and I found something a bit problematic here : I have to set INPUT policy to ACCEPT and, in addition, to have a rule saying iptables -I INPUT -i eth0 -j ACCEPT. Here comes my script (launched manually for tests) : #… >>> More

Related posts about icmp

How to stop a ICMP attack?

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
We are under a heavy icmp flood attack. Tcpdump shows the result below. Altough we have blocked ICMP with iptables tcpdump still prints icmp packets. I've also attached iptables configuration and "top" result. Is there any thing I can do to completely stop icmp packets? [root@server downloads]# tcpdump… >>> More
xen 4.1 host priodically dropping network packets of domU

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I have xen 4.1 Host running on a ubuntu 12.04 LTS Server with ip 153.x.x.54. I have setup 2 VMs on it, namely, "dev.mydomain.com" and "web.mydomain.com" with ips 195.X.X.2 and 195.x.x.3 respectively. For network the VMs connect through xendbr0 (xen-bridge), and can accces the network properly. I… >>> More
Block IP Address including ICMP using UFW

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I prefer ufw to iptables for configuring my software firewall. After reading about this vulnerability also on askubuntu, I decided to block the fixed IP of the control server: 212.7.208.65. I don't think I'm vulnerable to this particular worm (and understand the IP could easily change), but wanted… >>> More
Linux router: ping doesn't route back

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I have a Debian box which I'm trying to set up as a router and an Ubuntu box which I'm using as a client. My problem is that when the Ubuntu client tries to ping a server on the Internet, all the packets are lost (though, as you can see below, they seem to go to the server and back without problem)… >>> More
Why isn't ICMP routing with iptables nat routing

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I'm using iptables on Ubuntu server to route a public IP to a private IP. I want to nat all traffic, including 80, 443 and ICMP. However, it appears that ICMP isn't routing. I have a steady ping going to the public IP and it never stops, even with NAT pointing to a bogus IP. Here are the rules… >>> More