Using VLANs that are routed together?
        Posted  
        
            by 
                dannymcc
            
        on Server Fault
        
        See other posts from Server Fault
        
            or by dannymcc
        
        
        
        Published on 2011-11-25T22:14:45Z
        Indexed on 
            2011/11/26
            1:55 UTC
        
        
        Read the original article
        Hit count: 553
        
I have a quick question that's bugging me the more I read about VLANs.
So far I understand that they are useful for dividing the network into sub-sections, but if you route them together does that not remove any security benefit?
As an example, if I created a VLAN on my home network which was simply one computer, one server and one router.if I wanted to divide the network between computers and servers I could put the computer on VLAN 10 and the server on VLAN 20. Then the computer would no longer be able to communicate with the server - unless I added a static route to the router that connected the two together, basically telling VLAN 10 that VLAN 20 exists and how to communicate with it.
The VLANs would then be connected in a similar way to a 'flat' network that has no VLANs. Therefore, surely, all security benefits are lost.
Am I missing something?
© Server Fault or respective owner