Gerrit code review, or Github's fork and pull model?

Posted by user1366476 on Programmers See other posts from Programmers or by user1366476
Published on 2012-11-01T20:43:19Z Indexed on 2012/11/01 23:19 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 283

Filed under:

github

|

forking

|

gerrit

I am starting a software project that will be team AND community developed. I was previously sold on gerrit, but now github's fork and pull request model seem to almost provide more tools, ways to visualize commits, and ease of use.

For someone who has at least a little experience with both, what are the pros/cons of each, and which would be better for a team based project which wants to leave open the possibility for community development?

© Programmers or respective owner

Related posts about github

Installing GitHub for Mac - "Github cannot be opened because of a probem"

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I'm trying to get started using Git for Mac, but I receive an error when I try to run the program. I'm new to GitHub and relatively new to Mac. First, I installed Git using the downloadable .dmg file named "git-1.7.12.3-intel-universal-snow-leopard". I ran the .pkg file contained therein and the… >>> More
update github project wiki through the github api

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Is there a way a developer can automatically upload documentation for his project hosted on github through their API? I didn't find anything on develop.github.com related to this. It would be nice if one could just scp the files or something. >>> More
Connecting git to github on windows 7 without bash

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm setting up git on my new Windows 7 machine and I'm hitting a roadblock when it comes to getting github to acknowledge my ssh key. I am doing things a little different from the standard script in that I would rather not use cygwin and prefer to use my powershell prompt. The following is what I… >>> More
Heroku and Github integration (how to structure the project)

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm creating a webservice and I want to store the source on github and run the app on heroku. I haven't seen my exact scenario addressed anywhere on the 'net so far, so I'll ask it here: I want to have the following directory structure: /project .git README <-- project readme file TODO… >>> More
Best practice: git, github, lighthouse and 2 developers

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm setting up a new project and plan on using git and github for sourcecontroll and hosting of repo and lighthouse for bugtracking. I've been working with git for some while now, but only been using it for more of a backup solution than collaborate coding solution. Also, I've noticed that in github… >>> More

Related posts about forking

iPhone programming - problem with CoreFoundation forking

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hello all, I've been working on an iPhone for several months. It's a 2d shooting game akin to the old Smash TV type games. I'm doing everything alone and it has come out well so far, but now I am getting unpredictable crashes which seem to be related to CoreFoundation forking and not exec()ing… >>> More
The viability of open source forking

as seen on Internet.com - Search for 'Internet.com'
<b>InfoWorld:</b> "Source code availability is a central factor in establishing trust in the open source community, as knowledge that the source is available can often allay fears about the future of a particular open source project or product. And yet, this trust can often be overstated… >>> More
What are the legal considerations when forking a BSD-licensed project?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I'm interested in forking a project released under a two-clause BSD license: Copyright (c) 2010 {copyright holder} All rights reserved. Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions are met: … >>> More
Why fork a library for your own application?

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
Why should a programmer ever fork a library for inclusion in a widely used application? I ask this question because I was reading an article about why Chromium isn't packaged for many Linux distros like Fedora. Apparently its largely due to the fact that Google has forked a number of libraries, modified… >>> More
Forking project on Github process

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
There is a project on Github that I mostly like and want to use. There are a few things I want to do differently/remove that doesn't make sense for what I want/need. Also I want to add a few things as well. As I understand it, I should fork the project and I can make whatever changes I want and push… >>> More