Should a Unit-test replicate functionality or Test output?
- by Daniel Beardsley
I've run into this dilemma several times. Should my unit-tests duplicate the functionality of the method they are testing to verify it's integrity? OR Should unit tests strive to test the method with numerous manually created instances of inputs and expected outputs?
I'm mainly asking the question for situations where the method you are testing is reasonably simple and it's proper operation can be verified by glancing at the code for a minute.
Simplified example (in ruby):
def concat_strings(str1, str2)
return str1 + " AND " + str2
end
Simplified functionality-replicating test for the above method:
def test_concat_strings
10.times do
str1 = random_string_generator
str2 = random_string_generator
assert_equal (str1 + " AND " + str2), concat_strings(str1, str2)
end
end
I understand that most times the method you are testing won't be simple enough to justify doing it this way. But my question remains; is this a valid methodology in some circumstances (why or why not)?
