RESTful idempotence
- by DutrowLLC
I'm designing a RESTful web service utilizing ROA(Resource oriented architecture).
I'm trying to work out an efficient way to guarantee idempotence for PUT requests that create new resources in cases that the server designates the resource key.
From my understanding, the traditional approach is to create a type of transaction resource such as /CREATE_PERSON. The the client-server interaction for creating a new person resource would be in two parts:
Step 1: Get unique transaction id for creating the new PERSON resource:::
**Client request:**
GET /CREATE_PERSON
**Server response:**
200 OK
transaction-id:"as8yfasiob"
Step 2: Create the new person resource in a request guaranteed to be unique by using the transaction id:::
**Client request**
PUT /CREATE_PERSON/{transaction_id}
first_name="Big bubba"
**Server response**
201 Created // (If the request is a duplicate, it would send this
PersonKey="398u4nsdf" // same response without creating a new resource. It
// would perhaps send an error response if the was used
// on a transaction id non-duplicate request, but I have
// control over the client, so I can guarantee that this
// won't happen)
The problem that I see with this approach is that it requires sending two requests to the server in order to do to single operation of creating a new PERSON resource. This creates a performance issues increasing the chance that the user will be waiting around for the client to complete their request.
I've been trying to hash out ideas for eliminating the first step such as pre-sending transaction-id's with each request, but most of my ideas have other issues or involve sacrificing the statelessness of the application.
Is there a way to do this?
