Is System.AddIn mostly about making it easier to use Remoting or does it make it harder to do so?

Posted by MatthewMartin on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by MatthewMartin
Published on 2009-11-15T05:26:40Z Indexed on 2010/03/28 18:13 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 320

Filed under:

system.addin

|

maf

|

.net-bcl

|

remoting

|

.net-remoting

It takes at least 7 assemblies and restricting my AddIn's data model to data types that remoting can deal with before the appdomain isolation features begin to work. It is so complex! The System.AddIn teams blog implies to me they were trying to re-create a mental model of COM, a model I never understood very well in the first place and am not sold on the benefits. (If COM is so good why's it dead?-rhetorical question.) If I don't need to mirror or interop with legacy COM (like VSTO does using System.AddIn), is it possible to just create some classes that load load in a new AppDomain?

I can write the discovery code my self, I've done it before and a naive implementation is pretty fast because I'm not like iterating over the assemblies in the GAC!

So my specific question is, can I get the AppDomain isolation that AddIns provide with a few code Remoting snippets, and what would those be?

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about system.addin

Is System.AddIn mostly about making it easier to use Remoting or does it make it harder to do so?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
It takes at least 7 assemblies and restricting my AddIn's data model to data types that remoting can deal with before the appdomain isolation features begin to work. It is so complex! The System.AddIn teams blog implies to me they were trying to re-create a mental model of COM, a model I never understood… >>> More
Application Architecture using WCF and System.AddIn

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
A little background -- we're designing an application that uses a client/server architecture consisting of: A server which loads server-side modules, potentially developed by other teams. A client which loads corresponding client-side modules (also potentially developed by those other teams; each… >>> More
addins deployment

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hello Everyone, we have a product that work as standalone and Clickonce , we created some components as addins in the system (based on microsoft System.addin) we need a mechanism to update this addins on the customers in the two cases stand and click once I'm thinking for the stand alone we just… >>> More
Executing untrusted code

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, I'm building a C# application which uses plug-ins. The application must guarantee to the user that plug-ins will not do whatever they want on the user machine, and will have less privileges that the application itself (for example, the application can access its own log files, whereas plug-ins… >>> More

Related posts about maf

New MAF Episode on Listeners and Events.

as seen on Oracle Blogs - Search for 'Oracle Blogs'
We've sneaked in an extra episode into the UI Development playlist of the MAF online training. You can access the new episode on Listeners and Events here. Note, that we've renumbered all of the subsequent episodes (just incase you were referring back to the episodes by number. This… >>> More
New MAF Episode on Listeners and Events.

as seen on Oracle Blogs - Search for 'Oracle Blogs'
We've sneaked in an extra episode into the UI Development playlist of the MAF online training. You can access the new episode on Listeners and Events here. Note, that we're renumbered all of the subsequent episodes (just incase you were referring back to the episodes by number. This… >>> More
C# WPF MAF Add-In interaction between themselves

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, I would like create a very simple Paint application using MAF on WPF. The Add Ins I would like to create are: Main Image Processor - Shown the current paint Tool Box - The user can select some types of drawings tools Layers - The user can select the layers to display, delete layers and select… >>> More
Plugin Framework - can there be too many addin assemblies?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, The product I'm working on needs to be built in such a way that we have a quote engine driven by a pluggable framework. We are currently thinking of using MAF, so we can leverage separation of the host and addin interfaces for versioning. However, I'm concerned that we'd have lots of assemblies… >>> More
Is System.AddIn mostly about making it easier to use Remoting or does it make it harder to do so?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
It takes at least 7 assemblies and restricting my AddIn's data model to data types that remoting can deal with before the appdomain isolation features begin to work. It is so complex! The System.AddIn teams blog implies to me they were trying to re-create a mental model of COM, a model I never understood… >>> More