Code Golf: Evaluating Mathematical Expressions

Posted by Noldorin on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Noldorin
Published on 2009-05-29T23:43:13Z Indexed on 2010/04/18 17:43 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 419

Filed under:
|
|
|
|

Challenge

Here is the challenge (of my own invention, though I wouldn't be surprised if it has previously appeared elsewhere on the web).

Write a function that takes a single argument that is a string representation of a simple mathematical expression and evaluates it as a floating point value. A "simple expression" may include any of the following: positive or negative decimal numbers, +, -, *, /, (, ). Expressions use (normal) infix notation. Operators should be evaluated in the order they appear, i.e. not as in BODMAS, though brackets should be correctly observed, of course. The function should return the correct result for any possible expression of this form. However, the function does not have to handle malformed expressions (i.e. ones with bad syntax).

Examples of expressions:

1 + 3 / -8                            = -0.5       (No BODMAS)
2*3*4*5+99                            = 219
4 * (9 - 4) / (2 * 6 - 2) + 8         = 10
1 + ((123 * 3 - 69) / 100)            = 4
2.45/8.5*9.27+(5*0.0023)              = 2.68...

Rules

I anticipate some form of "cheating"/craftiness here, so please let me forewarn against it! By cheating, I refer to the use of the eval or equivalent function in dynamic languages such as JavaScript or PHP, or equally compiling and executing code on the fly. (I think my specification of "no BODMAS" has pretty much guaranteed this however.) Apart from that, there are no restrictions. I anticipate a few Regex solutions here, but it would be nice to see more than just that.

Now, I'm mainly interested in a C#/.NET solution here, but any other language would be perfectly acceptable too (in particular, F# and Python for the functional/mixed approaches). I haven't yet decided whether I'm going to accept the shortest or most ingenious solution (at least for the language) as the answer, but I would welcome any form of solution in any language, except what I've just prohibited above!

My Solution

I've now posted my C# solution here (403 chars). Update: My new solution has beaten the old one significantly at 294 chars, with the help of a bit of lovely regex! I suspected that this will get easily beaten by some of the languages out there with lighter syntax (particularly the funcional/dynamic ones), and have been proved right, but I'd be curious if someone could beat this in C# still.

Update

I've seen some very crafty solutions already. Thanks to everyone who has posted one. Although I haven't tested any of them yet, I'm going to trust people and assume they at least work with all of the given examples.

Just for the note, re-entrancy (i.e. thread-safety) is not a requirement for the function, though it is a bonus.


Format

Please post all answers in the following format for the purpose of easy comparison:

Language

Number of characters: ???

Fully obfuscated function:

(code here)

Clear/semi-obfuscated function:

(code here)

Any notes on the algorithm/clever shortcuts it takes.


© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about code-golf

  • Code Golf: Collatz Conjecture

    as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
    Inspired by http://xkcd.com/710/ here is a code golf for it. The Challenge Given a positive integer greater than 0, print out the hailstone sequence for that number. The Hailstone Sequence See Wikipedia for more detail.. If the number is even, divide it by two. If the number is odd, triple… >>> More

  • Code Golf - p day

    as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
    The Challenge The shortest code by character count to display a representation of a circle of radius R using the *character, followed by an approximation of p. Input is a single number, R. Since most computers seem to have almost 2:1 ratio you should only output lines where y is odd. The approximation… >>> More

  • Code Golf - PI day

    as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
    The Challenge The shortest code by character count to display a representation of a circle of radius R using the *character. Followed by an approximation of pi Input is a single number, R Since most computers seem to have almost 2:1 ratio you should only output lines where y is odd. The approximation… >>> More

  • Code Golf: Triforce

    as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
    This is inspired by/taken from this thread: http://www.allegro.cc/forums/thread/603383 The Problem Assume the user gives you a numeric input ranging from 1 to 7. Input should be taken from the console, arguments are less desirable. When the input is 1, print the following: *********** *********… >>> More

  • Code Golf: Tic Tac Toe

    as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
    Post your shortest code, by character count, to check if a player has won, and if so, which. Assume you have an integer array in a variable b (board), which holds the Tic Tac Toe board, and the moves of the players where: 0 = nothing set 1 = player 1 (X) 2 = player 2 (O) So, given the array b… >>> More

Related posts about math