Each time we add a new layer to our OpenLayers based website (data provided primarily by a GeoServer server), we discuss whether to use a single-tile or a tiled approach.

Some of the parameters we evaluate are the following:

Using the tiled approach we get:

• Slow but continuous buildup of the viewport
• Lots of small images
• Client side caching possibilities
• Blocking of the loading pipeline (6 requests at a time)
• Jerky feeling when navigating during load

Using the single-tile approach we get:

• Smoother feeling when navigating during load
• Time delay before layer is loaded
• One large image for each layer
• No caching of the single tile

We have a lot of data editing in the layers, thus a tile-cache might not be that efficient.

Are there any best-practices when it comes to tiling?

Progressing towards infinitely fast hardware and unlimited data connections, the discussion becomes irrelevant, but what configuration do you percieve as the most user-pleasing?