Efficient way to remove empty lists from lists without evaluating held expressions?

Posted by Alexey Popkov on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by Alexey Popkov
Published on 2011-07-10T13:49:36Z Indexed on 2012/10/22 11:01 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 157

Filed under:

In previous thread an efficient way to remove empty lists ({}) from lists was suggested:

Replace[expr, x_List :> DeleteCases[x, {}], {0, Infinity}]

Using the Trott-Strzebonski in-place evaluation technique this method can be generalized for working also with held expressions:

f1[expr_] := 
 Replace[expr, 
  x_List :> With[{eval = DeleteCases[x, {}]}, eval /; True], {0, Infinity}]

This solution is more efficient than the one based on ReplaceRepeated:

f2[expr_] := expr //. {left___, {}, right___} :> {left, right}

But it has one disadvantage: it evaluates held expressions if they are wrapped by List:

In[20]:= f1[Hold[{{}, 1 + 1}]]

Out[20]= Hold[{2}]

So my question is: what is the most efficient way to remove all empty lists ({}) from lists without evaluating held expressions? The empty List[] object should be removed only if it is an element of another List itself.


Here are some timings:

In[76]:= expr = Tuples[Tuples[{{}, {}}, 3], 4];
First@Timing[#[expr]] & /@ {f1, f2, f3}
pl = Plot3D[Sin[x y], {x, 0, Pi}, {y, 0, Pi}]; 
First@Timing[#[pl]] & /@ {f1, f2, f3}

Out[77]= {0.581, 0.901, 5.027}

Out[78]= {0.12, 0.21, 0.18}

Definitions:

Clear[f1, f2, f3];
f3[expr_] := 
  FixedPoint[
   Function[e, Replace[e, {a___, {}, b___} :> {a, b}, {0, Infinity}]], expr];
f1[expr_] := 
  Replace[expr, 
   x_List :> With[{eval = DeleteCases[x, {}]}, eval /; True], {0, Infinity}];
f2[expr_] := expr //. {left___, {}, right___} :> {left, right};

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about mathematica