Business Objects - Containers or functional?

Posted by Walter on Programmers See other posts from Programmers or by Walter
Published on 2010-10-06T09:39:57Z Indexed on 2012/11/14 23:18 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 457

Filed under:

business-logic

|

business-rules

This is a question I asked a while back on SO, but it may get discussed better here...

Where I work, we've gone back and forth on this subject a number of times and are looking for a sanity check. Here's the question: Should Business Objects be data containers (more like DTOs) or should they also contain logic that can perform some functionality on that object.

Example - Take a customer object, it probably contains some common properties (Name, Id, etc), should that customer object also include functions (Save, Calc, etc.)?

One line of reasoning says separate the object from the functionality (single responsibility principal) and put the functionality in a Business Logic layer or object.

The other line of reasoning says, no, if I have a customer object I just want to call Customer.Save and be done with it. Why do I need to know about another class to save a customer if I'm consuming the object?

Our last two projects have had the objects separated from the functionality, but the debate has been raised again on a new project.

Which makes more sense and why??

© Programmers or respective owner

Related posts about business-logic

Project structure: where to put business logic

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
First of all, I'm not asking where does business logic belong. This has been asked before and most answers I've read agree in that it belongs in the model: Where to put business logic in MVC design? How much business logic should be allowed to exist in the controller layer? How accurate is "Business… >>> More
Business Logic Layer Pattern on Rails? MVCL

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
That is a broad question, and I appreciate no short/dumb asnwers like: "Oh that is the model job, this quest is retarded (period)" PROBLEM Where I work at people created a system over 2 years for managing the manufacture process over demand in the most simplified still broad as possible, involving… >>> More
Does business logic belong in the service layer?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I've got a set of classes, namely, a data transfer object, a service implementation object, and a data access object. I currently have business logic in the service implementation object; it uses the dao to get data to populate the dto that is shipped back to the client/gui code. The issue is that… >>> More
Transforming Business Logic into Web Services Using DB2 9.5 and IBM Data Studio

as seen on Internet.com - Search for 'Internet.com'
Learn how to take business logic such as stored procedures, functions, or SQL statements and turn them into a Web service. >>> More
SQL Server 2008: CASE vs IF-ELSE-IF vs GOTO

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I have some rules in my application and I have written the business logic of that rules in my procedure. At the time of creation of procedure I came to know that CASE statement won't work in my scenario. So I have tried two ways to perform same operations (using IF-ELSE-IF or GOTO) shown as below… >>> More

Related posts about business-rules

BizTalk Business Rules Engine - Repeating Elements Question

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hello I'm trying to create what I think should be a relatively simple business rule to operate over repeating elements in an XML schema. Consider the following XML snippet (this is simplified with namespaces removed, for readability): <Root> <AllAccounts> <Account id="1" currentPayment="10… >>> More
Configure EnableTransaction and IsolationLevel property in Business Rules for Dynamic Send Port

as seen on Geeks with Blogs - Search for 'Geeks with Blogs'
Why do you want to add these properties to the BRE..?? There is a lot of performance issue when using WCF adapters with Dynamic Send Port. Please check the below link for more info. http://blogs.msdn.com/mdoctor/archive/2009/12/18/performance-tip-when-using-wcf-custom-with-dynamic-send-ports-and-custom-bindings-on-biztalk-server-2009… >>> More
Must-Have Business Rules for Today's Economy

as seen on Internet.com - Search for 'Internet.com'
Rules keep the business world moving forward so today we share Michelle LaBrosse's top ten rules for a successful business. >>> More
How do you keep your business rules DRY?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I periodically ponder how to best design an application whose every business rule exists in just a single location. (While I know there is no proverbial “best way” and that designs are situational, people must have a leaning toward one practice or another.) I work for a shop where they prefer to… >>> More
TDD - testing business rules/validation in ASP.NET MVC

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi, I am using the sharp architecture so I can easily use mocks etc. in my unit tests and/or during TDD. I have quite complicated business rules and would like to test them at the controller level. I am just wondering how other people do this? For me validation tests business rules at three levels: (1)… >>> More