The issue is this: Most things I read on the web says that we should avoid actions when creating popup menus because the command framework allows for more decoupling.

Example: http://wiki.eclipse.org/FAQ_What_is_the_difference_between_a_command_and_an_action%3F

Fair enough.

But I am having a heck of a time getting the command framework to add my menu when I right click on a .java file inside the editor, and only when I click inside the editor. I can get the menu to show (using 'with' and the activeEditor variable), but it also shows when I right click on the java file inside the package explorer, which I don't want. I suspect it's because the file is already open inside the editor.

I also have a menu that gets added when I right click on the java file inside the package explorer, using IComplilationUnit. That works fine.

So my problem is solved using a popup menu action for when I click inside the file. I also get access to to all the ISelection stuff there. But the coupling is to high and I lose the flexability of using handlers.

I'm looking for either: Tell me I'm doing it the only way possible; or Tell me how to have my popup appear only when I right click on the java file editor.

Regards