Live video streaming: Microsoft or Adobe ?

Posted by Kedare on Server Fault See other posts from Server Fault or by Kedare
Published on 2010-03-13T18:50:50Z Indexed on 2010/03/13 18:55 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 860

Filed under:

streaming

|

flash-media-server

|

windowsmediaservice

|

video-streaming

Hello,

I am looking for a Live Video Streaming solution,

The clients will be able to watch the video with a plugin (Flash or Silverlight), or a Standalone application (Windows Media Player, FLV, etc).

But I can't choose between Microsoft Solution (Windows Media Server (MMS, RTSP) + Silverlight as client) or the Adobe solution (Flash Media Server (RTMP) + Flash/Flex).

The streaming is for short duration cast and will not be online 24/24h.

I tried both, and I found the cheaper version of FMS don't provide security to prevent users to register as published (You have to write custom module...), the Windows Media Server provide this function.

We already have Windows Server licences. (So Windows Media Server will be "Free")

What do you recommend ? What is the best between Flash or Silverlight for Live Video Streaming ?

Thank you !

© Server Fault or respective owner

Related posts about streaming

Create NSC-File for multicast streaming with Windows Media Streaming

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
For streaming multicast I need to create a NSC-file for the players - this file is pseudo-coded by Microsoft. Now I need to create this file for each proxy-publishingpoint. Is there any way to stream multicast without the NSC-file or can I create the NSC-file on another way? Thanks for any idea ;) >>> More
Intranet Video-streaming

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
What's a good option for home-video-streaming. For example, somebody may use a laptop webcam to stream their baby's crib allowing them to monitor it from the main home PC. In this case, I wouldn't want to do it across the wire with skype, but instead keep it on my local network. What options exist… >>> More
How to use SQL file streaming win32 API and support WCF streaming

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm using Sql server file stream type to store large files in the backend. I'm trying to use WCf to stream the file across to the clients. I'm able to get the handle to the file using SQLFileStream (API). I then try to return this stream. I have implemenetd data chunking on the client side to retrive… >>> More
If Nvidia Shield can stream a game via WiFi (~150-300Mbps), where is the 1-10Gbps wired streaming?

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
Facts: It is surprising and uncharacteristic that a wireless game streaming solution is the *first to hit the market when a 1000mbps+ Ethernet connection would accomplish the same feat with roughly 6x the available bandwidth. 150-300mbps WiFi is in no way superior to a 1000mbps+ LAN connection aside… >>> More
VLC streaming testbench

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
Has anyone tried streaming media with VLC as server? I want to deploy VLC as streaming server, but my department didn't had a nice experience with VLC streaming. My question is has anyone tried VLC streaming over LAN with as many as 200 clients? What were the precautions to be taken before going… >>> More

Related posts about flash-media-server

Alternatives to Flash Media Server for multiplayer game development

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I've used Flash Media Server to create multiplayer flash games, but the cost of deploying a FMS application seems rather high. Are there good alternatives, open source or not, that I should look into to mimic the same functionality? I'm specifically looking at using FMS for the aspect of synching… >>> More
What are differences between Red5 and Flash Media Server

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I'm building a simple flash app that records user voice. I'm new to flash. What should I consider when choosing between red5 and flash media server? Can they both be hosted on EC2? Thanks! >>> More
Flash Media Server 3.5 Installation Problem.

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
Hello Experts, I installed Flash media server 3.5 in windows 7 home basic.it installed properly. When i try to open the media server,and not showing in its FMS ADMIN CONSOLE there. I have beeen checking the windows services, it shows flash media server is running.i have installed FMS in Default port… >>> More
Flash Media Server VS Sip Server: Difference for Voip

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
When using Flash Media Server and when using Sip Server ? What is the difference ? What would you recommend ? . Thanks ;) >>> More
Re-streaming RTMP stream

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I have a set of local RTMP stream servers in my network, but I want them to be reachable outside. The bandwidth is too narrow to serve multiple clients on the streamservers of my network, so the idea is to pull the local RTMP streams on a computer serving as a gateway, which pushes them on his turn… >>> More