Why avoid increment ("++") and decrement ("--") operators in JavaScript?
- by artlung
I'm a big fan of Douglas Crockford's writing on JavaScript, particularly his book JavaScript: The Good Parts. It's made me a better JavaScript programmer and a better programmer in general. One of his tips for his jslint tool is this :
++ and --
The ++ (increment) and -- (decrement)
operators have been known to contribute to bad code by
encouraging excessive trickiness. They
are second only to faulty architecture
in enabling to viruses and other
security menaces. There is a plusplus
option that prohibits the use of these
operators.
This has always struck my gut as "yes, that makes sense," but has annoyed me when I've needed a looping condition and can't figure out a better way to control the loop than a while( a < 10 )do { a++ } or for (var i=0;i<10;i++) { } and use jslint. It's challenged me to write it differently. I also know in the distant past using things, in say PHP like $foo[$bar++] has gotten me in trouble with off-by-one errors.
Are there C-like languages or other languages with similarities that that lack the "++" and "--" syntax or handle it differently?
Are there other rationales for avoiding "++" and "--" that I might be missing?
UPDATE -- April 9, 2010:
In the video Crockford on JavaScript -- Part 5: The End of All Things, Douglas Crockford addresses the ++ issue more directly and with more detail. It appears at 1:09:00 in the timeline. Worth a watch.
