General type conversion without risking Exceptions
- by Mongus Pong
I am working on a control that can take a number of different datatypes (anything that implements IComparable).
I need to be able to compare these with another variable passed in.
If the main datatype is a DateTime, and I am passed a String, I need to
attempt to convert the String to a DateTime to perform a Date comparison.
if the String cannot be converted to a DateTime then do a String comparison.
So I need a general way to attempt to convert from any type to any type. Easy enough, .Net provides us with the TypeConverter class.
Now, the best I can work out to do to determine if the String can be converted to a DateTime is to use exceptions. If the ConvertFrom raises an exception, I know I cant do the conversion and have to do the string comparison.
The following is the best I got :
string theString = "99/12/2009";
DateTime theDate = new DateTime ( 2009, 11, 1 );
IComparable obj1 = theString as IComparable;
IComparable obj2 = theDate as IComparable;
try
{
TypeConverter converter = TypeDescriptor.GetConverter ( obj2.GetType () );
if ( converter.CanConvertFrom ( obj1.GetType () ) )
{
Console.WriteLine ( obj2.CompareTo ( converter.ConvertFrom ( obj1 ) ) );
Console.WriteLine ( "Date comparison" );
}
}
catch ( FormatException )
{
Console.WriteLine ( obj1.ToString ().CompareTo ( obj2.ToString () ) );
Console.WriteLine ( "String comparison" );
}
Part of our standards at work state that :
Exceptions should only be raised when an Exception situation - ie. an error is encountered.
But this is not an exceptional situation. I need another way around it.
Most variable types have a TryParse method which returns a boolean to allow you to determine if the conversion has succeeded or not. But there is no TryConvert method available to TypeConverter. CanConvertFrom only dermines if it is possible to convert between these types and doesnt consider the actual data to be converted. The IsValid method is also useless.
Any ideas?
EDIT
I cannot use AS and IS. I do not know either data types at compile time. So I dont know what to As and Is to!!!
EDIT
Ok nailed the bastard. Its not as tidy as Marc Gravells, but it works (I hope). Thanks for the inpiration Marc. Will work on tidying it up when I get the time, but I've got a bit stack of bugfixes that I have to get on with.
public static class CleanConverter
{
/// <summary>
/// Stores the cache of all types that can be converted to all types.
/// </summary>
private static Dictionary<Type, Dictionary<Type, ConversionCache>> _Types = new Dictionary<Type, Dictionary<Type, ConversionCache>> ();
/// <summary>
/// Try parsing.
/// </summary>
/// <param name="s"></param>
/// <param name="value"></param>
/// <returns></returns>
public static bool TryParse ( IComparable s, ref IComparable value )
{
// First get the cached conversion method.
Dictionary<Type, ConversionCache> type1Cache = null;
ConversionCache type2Cache = null;
if ( !_Types.ContainsKey ( s.GetType () ) )
{
type1Cache = new Dictionary<Type, ConversionCache> ();
_Types.Add ( s.GetType (), type1Cache );
}
else
{
type1Cache = _Types[s.GetType ()];
}
if ( !type1Cache.ContainsKey ( value.GetType () ) )
{
// We havent converted this type before, so create a new conversion
type2Cache = new ConversionCache ( s.GetType (), value.GetType () );
// Add to the cache
type1Cache.Add ( value.GetType (), type2Cache );
}
else
{
type2Cache = type1Cache[value.GetType ()];
}
// Attempt the parse
return type2Cache.TryParse ( s, ref value );
}
/// <summary>
/// Stores the method to convert from Type1 to Type2
/// </summary>
internal class ConversionCache
{
internal bool TryParse ( IComparable s, ref IComparable value )
{
if ( this._Method != null )
{
// Invoke the cached TryParse method.
object[] parameters = new object[] { s, value };
bool result = (bool)this._Method.Invoke ( null, parameters);
if ( result )
value = parameters[1] as IComparable;
return result;
}
else
return false;
}
private MethodInfo _Method;
internal ConversionCache ( Type type1, Type type2 )
{
// Use reflection to get the TryParse method from it.
this._Method = type2.GetMethod ( "TryParse", new Type[] { type1, type2.MakeByRefType () } );
}
}
}
