PhysX for massive performance via GPU ?

Posted by devdude on Stack Overflow See other posts from Stack Overflow or by devdude
Published on 2009-06-02T14:18:47Z Indexed on 2010/04/14 22:33 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 451

Filed under:

game-development

|

physics

|

nvidia

|

comparison

|

physx

I recently compared some of the physics engine out there for simulation and game development. Some are free, some are opensource, some are commercial (1 is even very commercial $$$$). Havok, Ode, Newton (aka oxNewton), Bullet, PhysX and "raw" build-in physics in some 3D engines.

At some stage I came to conclusion or question: Why should I use anything but NVidia PhysX if I can make use of its amazing performance (if I need it) due to GPU processing ? With future NVidia cards I can expect further improvement independent of the regular CPU generation steps. The SDK is free and it is available for Linux as well. Of course it is a bit of vendor lock-in and it is not opensource.

Whats your view or experience ? If you would start right now with development, would you agree with the above ?

cheers

© Stack Overflow or respective owner

Related posts about game-development

Alternatives to Flash Media Server for multiplayer game development

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I've used Flash Media Server to create multiplayer flash games, but the cost of deploying a FMS application seems rather high. Are there good alternatives, open source or not, that I should look into to mimic the same functionality? I'm specifically looking at using FMS for the aspect of synching… >>> More
Learning about game development, any books recommended?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I want to write some games, but I don't have any game development experience. Any books are recommended? Is this necessary to have a good Maths skill when taking about some physical actions? Also, is it complex to do some AI design? thz a lot. >>> More
what are the problems in game development that requires scientific research? [on hold]

as seen on Game Development - Search for 'Game Development'
I been into Game Development for approximately 2 years for now mostly prototype development and testing ideas. Im in a point of my carrier where I am in a need to publish a research paper I would love to start doing research about game development however my lack of experience in actual game development… >>> More
Facebook Game Development - Which Programming languages?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
Hi folks, I am going to develop a facebook game as topic for my thesis. I am wondering which programming languages i should choice. I am used to programming in .NET. But i am also comfortable in C++ and Java. I don't want to use Flash as the graphical frontend since i don't like it. So i guess… >>> More
Facebook Game Development - .NET - Which architecture?

as seen on Stack Overflow - Search for 'Stack Overflow'
I am starting to develop a facebook game using ASP.NET + Silverlight Which architecture would you use? ASP.NET MVC or MVVM or RIA Services? ALso what do you think about using XNA with Silversprite? The game won't be a arcade game. It will be more strategy/RPG. Thanks a lot in advance. >>> More

Related posts about physics

How to implement friction in a physics engine based on "Advanced Character Physics"

as seen on Game Development - Search for 'Game Development'
I have implemented a physics engine based on the concepts in the classic text Advanced Character Physics by Thomas Jakobsen. Friction is only discussed very briefly in the article and Jakobsen himself notes how "other and better friction models than this could and should be implemented." Generally… >>> More
Approximating walking physics via simpler sliding physics

as seen on Game Development - Search for 'Game Development'
I am modeling walking insects. I implement them as cuboids and use forces (including friction and drag), to control motion. However, the movement characteristics of this 'sliding box' physics don't match those due to a legged creature. For example, legged creatures near-instantly accelerate to… >>> More
Sharing data between graphics and physics engine in the game?

as seen on Game Development - Search for 'Game Development'
I'm writing the game engine that consists of few modules. Two of them are the graphics engine and the physics engine. I wonder if it's a good solution to share data between them? Two ways (sharing or not) looks like that: Without sharing data GraphicsModel{ //some common for graphics and physics… >>> More
Keep basic game physics separate from basic game object? [on hold]

as seen on Game Development - Search for 'Game Development'
If anybody has dealt with a similar situation I'd be interested in your experience/wisdom, I'm developing a 2D game library in C++, I have game objects which have very basic physics, they also have movement classes attached to differing states, for example, a different movement type based on whether… >>> More
How can I split Excel data from one row into multiple rows

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
Good afternoon, Is there a way to split data from one row and store to separate rows? I have a large file that contains scheduling information and I'm trying to develop a list that comprises each combination of course, day, term and period per line. For example I have a file similiar to this: Crs:Sn… >>> More