SCOM 2007 versus Zenoss (or other open source)

Posted by TheCleaner on Server Fault See other posts from Server Fault or by TheCleaner
Published on 2009-07-08T02:39:43Z Indexed on 2010/05/21 14:41 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 1179

Filed under:

Windows

|

monitoring

|

scom

|

zenoss

I've taken the liberty to test both SCOM 2007 and Zenoss and found the following:

SCOM 2007

Pros:

Great MS Windows server monitoring and reporting
In-depth configuration and easily integrates into a "MS datacenter"

Cons:

limited network device monitoring support (without 3rd party plugins)
expensive
difficult learning curve

Zenoss

Pros:

Open Source (free)
decent server monitoring for Windows, great monitoring for Linux
decent network device monitoring

Cons:

not as in-depth as SCOM (for Windows at least)

So my question to you folks is this:

Given the above, and given that I'm trying to monitor 55 Windows servers, 1 Linux server, 2 ESX servers, and Juniper equipment...which would you recommend?

© Server Fault or respective owner

Related posts about Windows

Server 2012 DFS New Member Issue

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I am trying to add a new member to our DFS topology. We have 3 DCs (VMs - VMware) running Windows server 2012, two servers are located in or Primary site and the third at our DR site. Currently the two servers at our primary site are currently replicating DFS (full mesh) and are working fine. I have… >>> More
error in IIS7 but not on IIS6

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I have a website that is we are now deploying to windows 2008 servers that has worked in the past on IIS6 without a problem. It is using .net 2 framework. Most of the website works. Just when we create a screen report over a certain size on the server we get this error. Event code: 3005 Event… >>> More
error in IIS7 but not on IIS6

as seen on Server Fault - Search for 'Server Fault'
I have a website that is we are now deploying to windows 2008 servers that has worked in the past on IIS6 without a problem. It is using .net 2 framework. Most of the website works. Just when we create a screen report over a certain size on the server we get this error. Event code: 3005 Event… >>> More
Microsoft Management Console stops working when I add snap-in to it

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I have Windows 7 Ultimate OS. I'm opening mmc.exe as administrator and trying add Certificates or any other snap-in, then while loading that snap-in MMC breaks and displays following message and after that it closes automatically once I click on close button on that message. What could be the problem… >>> More
Handling keyboard and mouse input (Win API)

as seen on Game Development - Search for 'Game Development'
There is a number of ways to catch mouse or keyboard under Windows. So I tried some of them, but every of them has some advantages and drawbacks. I want to ask you: Which method do use? I've tried these: WM_KEYDOWN/WM_KEYUP - Main disadvantage is that, I can't distinguish between left and right-handed… >>> More

Related posts about monitoring

Issues with signal handling [closed]

as seen on Programmers - Search for 'Programmers'
I am trying to actually study the signal handling behavior in multiprocess system. I have a system where there are three signal generating processes generating signals of type SIGUSR1 and SIGUSR1. I have two handler processes that handle a particular type of signal. I have another monitoring process… >>> More
JMX Based Monitoring - Part Two - JVM Monitoring

as seen on Oracle Blogs - Search for 'Oracle Blogs'
This the second article in the series focussing on the JMX based monitoring capabilities possible with the Oracle Utilities Application Framework. In all versions of the Oracle utilities Application Framework, it is possible to use the basic JMX based monitoring available with the Java Virtual Machine… >>> More
JMX Based Monitoring - Part Three - Web App Server Monitoring

as seen on Oracle Blogs - Search for 'Oracle Blogs'
In the last blog entry I showed a technique for integrating a JMX console with Oracle WebLogic which is a standard feature of Oracle WebLogic 11g. Customers on other Web Application servers and other versions of Oracle WebLogic can refer to the documentation provided with the server to do a similar… >>> More
JMX Based Monitoring - Part Four - Business App Server Monitoring

as seen on Oracle Blogs - Search for 'Oracle Blogs'
In the last blog entry I talked about the Oracle Utilities Application Framework V4 feature for monitoring and managing aspects of the Web Application Server using JMX. In this blog entry I am going to discuss a similar new feature that allows JMX to be used for management and monitoring the Oracle… >>> More
Keeping track of File System Utilization in Ops Center 12c

as seen on Oracle Blogs - Search for 'Oracle Blogs'
Enterprise Manager Ops Center 12c provides significant monitoring capabilities, combined with very flexible incident management. These capabilities even extend to monitoring the file systems associated with Solaris or Linux assets. Depending on your needs you can monitor and manage incidents, or you… >>> More