Kernel NTFS driver vs NTFS-3G

Posted by Jack on Super User See other posts from Super User or by Jack
Published on 2010-05-10T02:59:14Z Indexed on 2010/05/10 3:00 UTC
Read the original article Hit count: 722

Filed under:

ntfs

|

ntfs3g

|

linux

|

kernel

|

filesystems

A more comprehensive phrased question since I lost access to the other one.

I would ask that the other one be deleted, not this one, as it should not have been migrated in the first place.

There are currently two NTFS drivers available for Linux.

The NTFS driver included in the kernel, and the userspace NTFS-3G driver that makes use of FUSE.

By all accounts, NTFS-3G works perfectly.

My question then, is if the NTFS filesystem has been successfully reverse engineered, why have the kernel NTFS team not implemented the changes in their driver? At the moment it is still marked as experimental, and there is a good chance it will destroy your data.

Note: This has absolutely nothing to do with distributions...

© Super User or respective owner

Related posts about ntfs

NTFS and NTFS-3G

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
I have a netbook with Ubuntu Netbook 10.04 and a desktop with Mint 10 (~ Ubuntu Desktop 10.10) Both of them have read/write NTFS partitions mounted via /etc/fstab. And it works fine. Ive read on net, google, forums, and several posts here, that NTFS-3G is the driver that allows you to have full… >>> More
NTFS partitions hidden under EXT4 file system / partition...want to recover files from NTFS

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
I am new to ubuntu, but very impressed with the system. so one day i tried installing ubuntu 10.10 along with windows in dual boot first place it didnt get installed properly and during second attempt i could do it right but oh...i lost my windows 7 , here is my problem and what i have done till… >>> More
Kernel NTFS driver vs NTFS-3G

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
A more comprehensive phrased question since I lost access to the other one. I would ask that the other one be deleted, not this one, as it should not have been migrated in the first place. There are currently two NTFS drivers available for Linux. The NTFS driver included in the kernel, and the… >>> More
NTFS partitions hidden under EXT4 file system / partion...want to recover files from NTFS

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
Hi all, I am new to ubuntu, but very impressed with the system. so one day i tried installing ubuntu 10.10 along with windows in dual boot first place it didnt get installed properly and during second attempt i could do it right but oh...i lost my windows 7 , here is my problem and what i have done… >>> More
Can't write to NTFS formatted drives

as seen on Ask Ubuntu - Search for 'Ask Ubuntu'
I'm not sure what has happened, but I've all of a sudden lost write access to any of my NTFS external drives. I installed a few games and apps from the software center, and now I can't make new folders or copy and paste files to anything that is NTFS. Everything is now read only, and I've tried… >>> More

Related posts about ntfs3g

How can I get Snow Leopard to recognize my third partition?

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I installed Snow Leopard on my Macbook Pro. I then installed Windows 7 in a Boot Camp partition. Then using Windows 7's disk management console, I resized my Windows 7partition and created a 3rd NTFS partition for data, intending for both Windows 7 and Snow Leopard to read/write this partition. I… >>> More
Kernel NTFS driver vs NTFS-3G

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
A more comprehensive phrased question since I lost access to the other one. I would ask that the other one be deleted, not this one, as it should not have been migrated in the first place. There are currently two NTFS drivers available for Linux. The NTFS driver included in the kernel, and the… >>> More
Opinions on NTFS for Mac solution?

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I am currently using the free NTFS-3G to access my NTFS drive from the Mac. It seems pretty stable (except once in the very beginning, it locked up the Mac and corrupted my NTFS drive, which I then fixed with chkdsk from a PC). However, speed is NOT one of its virtues. In fact, it's painfully… >>> More
Any opinions on Paragon's NTFS for Mac solution?

as seen on Super User - Search for 'Super User'
I am currently using the free NTFS-3G to access my NTFS drive from the Mac. It seems pretty stable (except once in the very beginning, it locked up the Mac and corrupted my NTFS drive, which I then fixed with chkdsk from a PC). However, speed is NOT one of its virtues. I've been looking at… >>> More